Brexit camp’s anti-immigration push caps sterling
Ken Odeluga June 7, 2016 6:02 PM
<p>The issue of immigration has been the most effective campaigning topic for the Leave campaign, and has also stopped sterling’s recovery in its tracks.</p>
Sterling’s steady recovery from 7-year lows is in jeopardy as the Leave campaign edges ahead by pressing its anti-immigration message.
It might not be palatable to everyone, but in British politics, often, the ‘immigration angle’ works.
Ask the Leave campaign.
Up until the beginning of the month, poll after poll gave Remain a consistent lead, even if it was a modest one. The Brexit campaign’s luck began to change on the last day of May, with an ORB poll suggesting 46% of voters would choose the ‘Leave’ option compared to 51% who said they’d Remain. The gap had been cut by almost two thirds in the course of a week.
The big shift came hot on the heels of the most up-to-date figures on immigration to the UK. These revealed that immigration was likely to add a record intake of 4 million people to Britain’s population.
It also appeared that Brexiters had kept immigration as an ‘ace up their sleeve’ up until that point. The topic only became a formative and concerted line of attack late in May. That’s when key ‘Leave’ campaigners Boris Johnson and Michael Gove began lambasting Prime Minister David Cameron over his failure to contain the number of people settling in the UK from overseas to tens of thousands rather than millions.
In many senses the Remain camp has been on the back foot ever since, and this has been reflected in sterling.
The Leave camp’s more determined push on immigration and Remain’s dwindling poll lead also coincided with the end of a recovery trend by the pound against the dollar from prices in March that had not been seen since 2009.
Between early March and the end of April, the pound rose almost 8% against the dollar. But it has failed to hold on to gains in its most widely traded pairing and against all other major currencies.
Likewise, a day has seldom passed since early May without the ‘Leave’ campaign pressing the immigration button hard. Their efforts have borne fruit: the best odds for a Brexit emerged last week at 3/1. Even shockingly weak US monthly employment figures on Friday failed to draw a line under the pound’s decline. On Monday morning, sterling tumbled as much as 150 price points (about one per cent) against the dollar, after ICM’s second poll in 48 hours showed Leave ahead of Remain, extending its lead by a couple of percentage points.
Over the weekend, the Leave camp may have received some apparently unsolicited help from UKIP leader Nigel Farage. Whilst not an official Leave member, and even occasionally a vehement critic, when asked whether incidents like the sex attacks reported in Germany on New Year’s eve could occur in Britain, his reply was predictably on message: “It depends if we vote for Brexit or not. It is an issue.”
The big question for ‘Leave’ strategists is whether the camp’s current advantage can be sustained, or whether it represents a ‘protest’ vote that will evaporate closer to 23rd June. Around 20% of voters have yet to decide which way they will vote, according to most polls released over the last few weeks.
For traders of sterling that key question goes hand-in-hand with another: whether a clear line of support that has contained cable’s decline since the middle of last month will give way.
The level is close to $1.43, the closing price of the week ending on Friday 13th May ($1.4361 to be precise) when the pound lost 1.3% week-on-week. The rate’s lowest price during the week that followed was only fractionally weaker, confirming c.$1.43 as a level the market regards as pivotal. In currencies and other financial markets, typically, when the ability of such levels to ‘support’ prices ends, declines quicken.
In other words, if the Leave campaign continues to make headway by deploying ‘immigration’, there is a high risk that sterling’s decline would accelerate.
‘Leave’ are likely to keep pressing hard on the immigration nerve during the next two weeks or so left of campaigning, particularly at or soon after the events listed below (all times are in British Summer Time).
- 7th June, 9pm: Prime Minister David Cameron, Nigel Farage - ITV Referendum Debate.
- 8th June 8, 7pm: Chancellor of the Exchequer George Osborne to be interviewed by BBC political journalist Andrew Neil
- 15th June, 6.45pm: BBC Question Time Special (part 1) with Michael Gove, Justice Secretary
- 17th June, 8.30pm: Iain Duncan Smith, former Work & Pensions Secretary who backs Brexit, to be interviewed by Andrew Neil
- 17th June, 8.30pm: Nigel Farage and Hilary Benn, Labour’s shadow foreign secretary, also likely to be quizzed at key campaign events
- 19th June, 6.45pm: BBC Question Time special (part 2) with PM Cameron
- 21st June, 8pm: the BBC’s EU referendum “Great Debate” to be held at Wembley Arena
We expect sterling to remain sensitive to the use of ‘the immigration issue’ by the Brexit campaign.
We expect the pound’s sensitivity to the issue to be particularly visible if the topic scores highly in swaying voter sentiment further toward a ‘Leave’ vote during the key events listed above.
To be clear, we are not suggesting that all traders agree with the Leave camp’s views on immigration. Simply that sterling will reflect the topic’s long-standing effectiveness for galvanising large swathes of British voters.
Please click image to enlarge; source Thomson Reuters/City Index
From a long-term technical perspective, $1.4361/$1.4330 mentioned above is close to a 38.2% ($1.4633) Fibonacci interval of cable’s decline from the 2015 highs notched about a year ago, to this year’s lows in March at 1.3868. $1.4633 may therefore set the medium-term peak for the rate, certainly until the 23rd June referendum date has passed. Traders will also be keen to see whether cable essentially continues to respect the weekly ‘double bottom’ near $1.43 mentioned above. Should that break, the next most magnetic prices would probably be near April 2009 volume-weighted lows and the 2015 low (set in May that year) around $1.4230, over 200 pips from Monday evening prices.
Cable’s prospects are weakened by a descending trend from June 2015, visible in the weekly view. The rate has failed to penetrate the trend sustainably, though longer-term momentum (Relative Strength Index sub-chart) looks neutral-to-somewhat bearish.
StoneX Financial Ltd (trading as “City Index”) is an execution-only service provider. This material, whether or not it states any opinions, is for general information purposes only and it does not take into account your personal circumstances or objectives. This material has been prepared using the thoughts and opinions of the author and these may change. However, City Index does not plan to provide further updates to any material once published and it is not under any obligation to keep this material up to date. This material is short term in nature and may only relate to facts and circumstances existing at a specific time or day. Nothing in this material is (or should be considered to be) financial, investment, legal, tax or other advice and no reliance should be placed on it.
No opinion given in this material constitutes a recommendation by City Index or the author that any particular investment, security, transaction or investment strategy is suitable for any specific person. The material has not been prepared in accordance with legal requirements designed to promote the independence of investment research. Although City Index is not specifically prevented from dealing before providing this material, City Index does not seek to take advantage of the material prior to its dissemination. This material is not intended for distribution to, or use by, any person in any country or jurisdiction where such distribution or use would be contrary to local law or regulation.